History - Page 5

Glory of the Innocents: Dieppe Decoded by Richard Tomkies

On May 28th of this year I had received an email from Mr. Richard Tomkies, who had in his possession, “remarkable video material professionally recorded in Dieppe during the 50th Anniversary in 1992.”

Mr. Tomkies would go on to say, “Dieppe of course, was not an error but a deliberate sacrifice, pivotal to success in Normandy and ultimately, victory in WWII.”

2017 happened to mark the 75th Anniversary of the Dieppe Raid; 19th August, 1942. On this day, the Allies had launched the largest military raid in history.

Thinking on this I began to research the involvement of the Canadian Army Film & photo Unit (CFPU) , and their preparations for one of the greatest operations of the war. The CFPU, being formed in October, 1941, was almost one year old at the time and aching to get sent into action, having been relegated to parades, and drills up to this point.

The first thing that came to mind was an article recommend to me by someone I had interviewed back in February, 2009; George Powell. Mr. Powell served Canada as a soldier in the Signals Corps through WWII, and later was assigned to The Maple Leaf as a journalist.

The article was written by Mr. Powell;

War correspondents, PR unit overlooked: Photographers and cameramen went into action with soldiers (George Powell. The Ottawa Citizen. Dec 23, 1998.)

In the article Mr. Powell describes the roles and duties of the CFPU;

“CFPU personnel were combatant soldiers drawn from all branches of the Army. In 1942, a shortage of cameramen resulted in only one Canadian still photographer participating in the Dieppe raid…” NOTE: (George W. Powell would later pass away July 11, 2011)

I thought this was odd, and looked deeper into my notes all the while thinking back on Mr. Tomkies’ view that Dieppe “was not an error but a deliberate sacrifice…”

I eventually came across a letter within the Public Relations files held at Library & Archives Canada, written by Lieut. J.E.R. McDougall, Canadian Army Film Unit (P.R.O.) Canadian Military Headquarters, dated 23rd, July, 1942;

“For your information due to the recent arrival of two new hand cameras, the Film Unit is now in a position to put three cameramen into the field should any operations take place. These three would consist of one officer and two other ranks. I have already passed this information along to Major Wallace.”

It seemed the CFPU was going to get their chance;

“At 1730 hrs, 14 August, 1942 a request reached the P.R.O. office at C.M.H.Q. from Major Wallace, P.R.O. Army, for Cpl. (Alan) Grayston of the Film Unit to report with Lieut. (Frank) Royal the next morning for an unspecified job. Grayston was unavailable, being engaged in another job, so Pte. (George) Cooper, an equally competent cameraman, was sent in his place.”

However, circumstances had changed by the time they arrived. Lieut. McDougall goes on;

“Upon arrival at Army H.Q., Lieut. Royal was told that the job was ‘not important’ enough to warrant sending two men, and Cooper was sent back to C.M.H.Q.”

To compound things further, it was learned later that three British Army Film Unit cameramen, two of their still photographers and one civilian newsreel cameraman were assigned to accompany the Dieppe operation. Clearly upset at the change, and without an explanation, Lieut. McDougall expressed his disappointment;

“I have had no explanation from P.R.O Army, and can conceive of none, why our cameraman, Pte. Cooper was returned to C.M.H.Q., after having been requested, and when an operation was impending. In any event, we should have been asked to supply three cameramen rather than one. Where the fault lies I have no way of knowing, but the fact remains that we had a definite job to do, we were trained, prepared and equipped to do it, and when the time came to do it we were deliberately ignored.”

Lieut. McDougall was so upset that he requested to be replaced by “someone possibly of lower medical category [who] could handle my job and free me for combatant duties.”

Like Lieut. McDougall, I am left wondering why? What was it about Dieppe that C.H.H.Q. did not send highly trained cameramen into what was largely a Canadian operation? Going back to the email, I invited Mr. Richard Tomkies, to present here in his words, his thoughts on Dieppe…

Intro – Richard Tomkies – Documentary Writer/Researcher

“I’ll tell you what I think”
“I was in Fairbanks, Alaska, filming an Alaska Highway 50th Anniversary event, when the truth of Dieppe hit me in a real Russian bear-hug! A Russian Vet-pilot asked me where I was from.
“Canada” I told him.
“Canada?” he bellowed, “I love Canada! Canada win war!” He spilled his vodka down my back with the hug!
“How? I asked him, “How Canada win war?”
“Dieppe!” he yelled, all smiles. “Canada die in Dieppe. Canada win war!”. He went off for more vodka.
Those few crazy words set me on a long road of research. Step by logical step, I came to realize that the Dieppe Raid, far from a tragic cock-up, was the launch of a brilliant strategy to win WW2 in Europe. In this light, the horror of Dieppe becomes deliberate; not a defeat but a victorious action of diabolical genius. Let’s recap what happened that morning in Dieppe, before we delve deeper into what really happened …

The Dieppe Action:

Just after 1:00 a.m. On August 19 th , 1942, the Allies launched the largest military raid in history. Target: the port town of Dieppe on the Pas de Calais coast of France. Of the 6,106 troops involved, 4,963 were Canadians, 1,075 were British, 50 were American and 20 inter-allied, meaning ‘other’.
The raiding force comprised 237 vessels, supported by 8 Hunt-Class destroyers, 800 aircraft and 58 tanks.
Just before dawn, the assault began at 5 points across a 16-km front. 4 simultaneous flank attacks went in first, soon followed by the main attack on the town. Canadians formed the bulk of this force. 6 hours’ later, it was all over: an apparent, bloody failure. 913 Canadians were dead. 1,946 were prisoners of war. Also killed: 52 British troops, 1 American, 62 RAF pilots and 72 British sailors. Only one assault group achieved its objective: Lord Lovat’s No.4 Commando. Operating independently, it successfully destroyed a battery near Varengeville, 8kms west of Dieppe, and withdrew safely.

The Official Why:

Neither before The Raid, nor since,has there ever been given a clear, cogent reason for it. Explanations have been offered, along with apologetic possibilities, but never a solid, strategic objective to justify a raid of such magnitude. This apparent strategic anomaly would mystify General Conrad Hasse, the officer commanding German forces around Dieppe. “It was too big for a raid, to small for an invasion. I cannot understand what they hoped to accomplish – unless the objectives were covert” Hasse reported to Hitler.
The lack of a clear objective has led historians on an elusive quest to find one. After 75 years, none has advanced beyond educated guesses.
What is so astonishing is that not a single historian, none of the pundits, has ever approached the record, their quest to fill the “wanting” gaps, with a truly open mind. Had they done so, had they not been blinkered by witch-hunt fever, they may well have considered the rather obvious possibility that Dieppe was not a mistake at all, that the bloodbath may well have been a strategic, sacrificial success, the bloodier the better.
Many aspects of Dieppe’s mysteriousness become less so in this light; many anomalies, so puzzling before, begin to make sense. In fact, it now seems more than likely that Dieppe was, indeed, the strategic success it was planned to be, that the time has come for this truth to be told.
-Richard Tomkies, Vancouver, 27th March, 1993-

The real “Why”? Wouldn’t you like to prove it?

To prove the real ‘why’? of Dieppe, we must examine what the Raid achieved and find evidence of planned intent to achieve it. Some fragmentary evidence has been found; much more remains hidden, some of it, perhaps, in plain sight! Let’s consider some highly relevant questions which seem to have highly relevant answers:
-Did Dieppe convince Stalin that, as Churchill promised him, Britain would soon invade Europe, and thus relieve German military pressure in Russia?
– Did Dieppe convince Stalin not to sign a cease-fire with Hitler, as was imminent, and keep Hitler fighting in Russia and not, as Hitler planned, invading Britain?
– Was Dieppe linked to Roosevelt&#;s decision to build The Alaska Highway, with regular airports along its route, to fly war supplies to Russia and keep Stalin fighting?
– Did Dieppe convince OSS Observers offshore that Roosevel’s plan to land in Europe and defeat Hitler there “in a few weeks” was unworkable? Better to land in Morocco?
– Why was the Dieppe raid, first canceled as Operation Rutter, remounted as Operation Jubilee after secrecy was breached and leaked?
– Was intentional sacrifice at Dieppe the reason Gen. Montgomery refused to command Jubilee and burned all his Rutter/Jubilee records – before Jubilee took place?
– Was deliberate death at Dieppe cause for orders after the raid – from Churchill and The London Controlling Section – that all records of the raid be expunged and burned?
– Did the horror at Dieppe cause Churchill to wire from Cairo – in response to Lord Ismay’s Dieppe report to him: “What raid ….?”
– Was planned sacrifice at Dieppe the reason Lord Lovat chose to conduct his successful
4 th Commando operation independently, outside the raid’s command?
– Was sacrifice at Dieppe death for Canadians because The Blitz and Dunkirk had demoralized the Brits, and the ANZACs still remembered Gallipoli?

Next Step to The Truth – Do you want to take it? A closing note from Richard Tomkies.

The stones are in London, Ottawa, Bonn, Washington and Moscow, even Pretoria, Aukland and Canberra; we know where they lie – all the serious researcher has to do is turn them over. The hints have drifted through time, seeped from leaks in vaults of secrecy; like pieces of a puzzle, disconnected and surprising, they are coming together to reveal the truth of Dieppe at last. It is not a pretty picture; it has a side of ugliness which chills the mind. Yet there is vivid courage in it, courage which offered a devastating sacrifice of blood to achieve as much, if not more, as any single action in WW11: the defeat of tyranny and the saving of civilisation.
We have an obligation to those who gave their lives, to their families, to Canada, to History, to reveal this truth.

Closing Appeal

As custodian of Richard Tomkies’ research material, along with his 50th Anniversary filmed interviews with Veterans in Dieppe, I will be pleased to share this material with those seriously interested in pursuing the truth of Dieppe, and, if required, put you in contact with Richard Tomkies.
Please contact me at:
webmaster@canadianfilm.com

As part of the Tomkies collection below, is a video extract made from selections by Mr. Richard Tomkies from the 12 BetaSP tapes he recorded of interviews with veterans he made during the 50th Anniversary in Dieppe.

DIEPPE 50TH ANNIVERSARY, 1992 ON-CAMERA INTERVIEWS: EXCERPTS – © RICHARD TOMKIES

In Their Words 08 – A Matter of Historical Value

I am a Canadian military veteran currently living in Phoenix, AZ. I have spent nights and weekends over the past few years publishing short duration non-commercial videos documenting Canada’s involvement in WW2. When I recently ran across a 1941 report by C.P. Stacey on the film recording of Canadian military activity, I was drawn to create a documentary on the subject of his report. Thought you might be interested in a link. Love the work you all do to preserve this facet of our history – please keep it up.

Sincerely,

George Saulnier

“A Matter of Historical Value”
YouTube Link: https://youtu.be/N6b5P3fz1pE

Ottawa Race Day – Vimy Challenge

///

Today was race day in Ottawa for the Canada Army Run;

In what turned out to be a beautiful day, over 20,000 converged on Laurier and Elgin Streets in Ottawa to participate in this unique military event.

“More than anything, though, Canada Army Run, is about Canadians and the Canadian Armed Forces – Air Force, Army, and Navy – joining together in the spirit of camaraderie and community. It’s a chance for the troops to extend the military esprit de corps to Canadians and to thank them for their support. And, it’s an opportunity for Canadians to say thanks to the men and women who serve them in so many ways at home and abroad.”

Unique for this year was the Vimy Challengewhere participants run, walk or roll officially in BOTH the 5K, presented by General Dynamics Mission Systems–Canada, and 10K events.” Vimy Challenge “was added to the 2017 Canada Army Run line-up to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the Battle of Vimy Ridge (First World War).” Also new this year was the introduction of Remembrance Row; “a section along the course showcasing signs of veterans who have passed away. These veterans are connected to you the participants, and we are calling on you for submissions.”

My submission for Remembrance Row was both Norman Quick, and Charles Ross, both of the Canadian Army Film & Photo Unit. Alas, only one of the profiles was allowed per participant and Norman Quick was selected to be featured along the course on race day.

The Vimy Challenge mandated that participants had to finish the first leg (5K) before the start of the second leg (10K), 45 minutes later. I knew that I could meet the requirement of running a 5K in under 45 minutes (from previous 5K Army Runs), but I forgot to take into account that with so many participants crowded at the start line, it might take me 10 minutes just to cross the start line!

Ultimately, I was able to ‘position’ myself close to the start line and was off without a problem. My next challenge was to locate Norman Quicks profile which I knew was featured somewhere along the race route. I spotted Norman Quicks profile along the Colonel By parkway, and decided I would grab some pictures during the second leg of the Challenge, the 10K. I wanted to keep going, feeling somewhat pressured to finish the 5K with time to regroup before the 10K.

In the end, it all worked out fine and I made the start of the 10K without a problem. When I happened upon Norms’ profile again, I stopped and struggled a bit to take a selfie of me and Norms’ profile. Fortunately, one of the participants made the effort to stop and took a few pictures of me posing with Norms profile. Big thank you to Mandy Wood for helping me out – it meant a lot to me!!

 

After the race I stopped by the Cenotaph to acknowledge the men and women who sacrificed their lives in service to Canada.

-Lest We Forget-

 

1 3 4 5 6 7 10